System Safety Engineering
  • Home
  • System Safety Engineering
  • Software Safety
  • Forensic Engineering
  • Human Factors
  • Organizational Factors
  • Risk

Effects of Shock

Hazards of human exposure to electricity depends more on the current than the voltage. The current resulting from a given voltage depends on the resistance of the body - typically tens of thousands of ohms for unbroken, dry skin. Can be as low as one thousand ohms if the skin is punctured or wet.


                                                    Current values (milliamperes)

Effects                       AC 25 Hz to 400 Hz                               DC
Perception                         0-1                                                0-4 
Surprise                                      1-4                                                4-15 
Reflex action                      4-21                                             15-80 
Muscular inhibition              21-40                                          80-160 
Respiratory block                40-100                                        160-300   
Usually fatal                         Over 100                                     Over 300 


                           Mil-Std-454   TABLE 1-I. Probable effects of shock.


Other Hazards

Reaction hazard
Caused by involuntary reaction to a shock. Not a direct problem if the current is low, but can be a safety problem if reaction causes a hazard (striking, falling, dropping, losing control).
Mitigations: Lockout/Tagout, proper grounding design.OSHA Lockout/Tagout. Also requirements for a Job Hazard Analysis (OSHA). Requirements do protect against contact with voltages over ~50 volts.Stray voltages caused by large ground currents can be a source of exposure. (Large ground currents can be caused by fault conditions or utility problems.)

Shock hazard
Caused by driving enough current through the body to cause ventricular fibrillation or tissue damage resulting in injury or death. Typically takes 10 or more milliamps driven through the body to start causing problems.
Typical mitigations: Use as low a voltage as possible. Prevent exposure with distance, insulation, grounded enclosure, interlocks or active detection systems (GFCIs). NFPA’s NEC and IEEE’s NESC provide most of the requirements. OSHA picks up requirements from both and from NFPA 70E. NEC requires grounded enclosures (conduit and boxes) to provide protection in normal and faulted conditions.

Requirements include: PPE (esp. high voltage), prevent contact, provide warning signs, training. Also Lockout/Tagout requirements (OSHA and KNPR 8715.4 KSC Lockout/Tagout Program Procedural Requirements). NEC has requirements for grounding, enclosing, protecting etc. and for GFCIs in specified locations. Separate requirements for specific locations (like lighting near pools, disconnects for air conditioning units) NESC takes over above 600 v.

Arc-flash
Explosion or arc (plasma at several thousand degrees) and spark (molten metal particles) caused by short circuit or the opening of a high voltage circuit. Can cause burns or start fires.Mitigations: De-energize, Barriers, PPE.Requirements: NFPA and OSHA have requirements for training and PPE. Five levels of PPE based on possible energy release.

Main Requirements

NFPA
     
      National Electrical Code (NFPA 70) – Covers buildings divided by “occupancy”.

      Standard for Electrical Safety in the Workplace (NFPA 70E) – Written for OSHA.
     
IEEE National Electrical Safety Code  – Covers work done by linemen and electricians.

OSHA Subpart S – Workplace safety; picks up parts of NFPA 70, 70E and NESC.
NASA NPR 8715.3 section 3.6 requires NFPA 70, Mil-Std-454 or Center-Specific requirements.

UL, ANSI and NEMA have lower-level standards for components, warning signs and enclosures.

Medical devices have their own standards with actual current limits.




Links

Wikipedia Article

How did Thomas Edison end up electrocuting an elephant?